← All games

Where the line runs

Whose answer is finished, whose is open, and how hard the machine has actually been set

What this puts together

Three pages here answer three parts of one question and never meet. The chronicle says when each game changed hands. The list of solved games says whose answer is finished and whose is still open. The score says what happens now, when somebody who is not a champion sits down against an engine in a browser tab. The row you actually want runs across all three.

So here they are in one table. The middle column is copied word for word from the solved list rather than retold — a retold fact drifts, and a year later a site disagrees with itself about who solved Othello. The last column is live: it is the hardest setting at which humans still take half of the finished matches, and it is blank wherever too few have been played to say anything at all.

Four kinds of answer appear. Known — perfect play has been computed and the result cannot change. Partly — computed for smaller boards only. Open — nobody knows. Not that question — an arcade duel or a measurement has no game-theoretic value to compute, and calling it unsolved would be a category error.

Game Is the answer known Where the line is now
AtaxxopenAtaxx 7×7 is unsolved; the result is unknownreading the shared score…
ReversiknownOthello 8×8 — Hiroki Takizawa, 2023: a drawreading the shared score…
Tronnot that questiona duel of reflexes, not a question with an answerreading the shared score…
Dots and BoxespartlyJoseph Barker and Richard Korf, 2012 — boards up to 4×5; the general case is openreading the shared score…
Battleshipnot that questiona hidden-information game: there is no value to computereading the shared score…
GomokuknownVictor Allis, 1993: the first player wins (free-style rules)reading the shared score…
Draughtsopenthese are the Russian rules, and they are unsolved. English draughts are — the Chinook team, 2007, after eighteen years of computationreading the shared score…
Bulls and Cowsnot that questionnot a contest over a board: both sides are breaking a codereading the shared score…
Backgammonopenunsolved: the dice get in the way, so no solution in the usual sense existsreading the shared score…
Pongnot that questionan arcade duel: the hand decides it, not a game treereading the shared score…
Nine Men's MorrisknownRalph Gasser, 1993: a drawreading the shared score…
Connect FourknownVictor Allis and James Allen independently, 1988: the first player winsreading the shared score…
MancalaknownKalah 6×4 — Geoffrey Irving, Jeroen Donkers and Jos Uiterwijk, 2000: the first player winsreading the shared score…
Evil 2048not that questionthe opponent does not play to win, it picks the tile that hurts mostreading the shared score…
Evil Threesnot that questionthe dealer is bound by the deck, but picks the order and the lane against youreading the shared score…
Evil Drop7not that questionthe column is yours; the disc and the numbers under the greys are the opponent'sreading the shared score…
Evil Suikanot that questionthe dealer runs the physics ahead and deals the worst fruitreading the shared score…
Mind Readernot that questiona test of randomness, not a matchreading the shared score…
Spot the Machinenot that questiondiscrimination, not a game: the answer moves with the modelsreading the shared score…
Reverse CAPTCHAnot that questiona measurement of sight, not a contestreading the shared score…
NimknownCharles Bouton, 1901: the side to move from a non-zero XOR winsoutside the score: at expert the start is rigged and no human move wins — that is a theorem, not a defeat
Minesweepernot that questionnot a two-player game; Richard Kaye, 2000 — deciding a safe move is NP-completeoutside the score: the mines fall at random, so nobody is playing against you

What this table does not say

It does not say people are weaker than machines in general. Every row is a task with clear rules, a clear score and an unlimited supply of practice games — the exact shape of problem where a machine has every advantage and a person has none. Nothing outside that shape is measured here, and most of a life is outside it.

And the last column moves for a reason that has nothing to do with anybody getting better or worse: it moves because games get played. A blank means nobody has called that machine out yet, which is not the same as losing to it. The chronicle in the first column is finished history; the last column is only as good as the evening somebody spent on it.