← Home

2019

3 processors and 3 events on the line between people and machines
In the world: Disney+. Game of Thrones ends. Notre-Dame burns. The first photo of a black hole.
What happened at the board
From the chronicle of the contest

~ 2019 · machine

StarCraft II and Dota 2

AlphaStar beats professionals at StarCraft II; OpenAI Five beats world champions OG at Dota 2. Incomplete information, real time and team coordination — the things that were supposed to stay human.

Both results came with caveats: limits on action rate, camera view and the pool of characters.

2019 · human

Debate: the human still wins

IBM's Project Debater argues live against world champion Harish Natarajan and loses on the audience vote. The machine collects arguments; it does not persuade.

11 July 2019 · machine

Pluribus: six-player poker

Heads-up is still a two-sided game with an equilibrium. Pluribus beats five professionals at once, and multiplayer games have no such tidy theory to lean on.

The machine of the year
Who sat down on the machine's side, and what it was built out of

2019 · poker · the machine won the match

Pluribus at a six-handed table

Two experiments of 10,000 hands each, six-player no-limit hold'em. Against five professionals the machine won 48 milli-big-blinds per hand; against one human and five copies of itself, 32. The blueprint strategy took 12,400 core hours and, by the authors' own arithmetic, about $144 of cloud rental.

Carnegie Mellon University and Facebook AI Research · the paper names no venue: play went through an interface built for the experiment

The match hardware
2 processors M · measured

The match passport: energy, price, latency, what was proved and what was not →

What it cost
The price is in the money of its own year; where there is none, this says why
Basis: rented computation
144 USD nominal, 2019 R · reconstructed

In 2025 money that is 181 USD. Converted through the consumer price index, from a snapshot of the series taken 2026-08-12 — not a live rate.

The figure comes from the primary source verbatim: 'At current cloud computing spot instance rates, this would cost about $144 to produce' — Brown and Sandholm, Science 365(6456), p. 887. The 'around $150' that circulates in retellings is a rounding of this one. What it covers: the blueprint computation only, 12,400 core hours on a 64-core server over eight days. What it does not cover: any actual bill — the machine was the group's own, not rented; the real-time search across the 20,000 hands played; the payments to the players ($50,000 among the participants of the first experiment, $2,000 each plus a possible $2,000 bonus in the second, funded by Facebook); and the years of laboratory work whose code, by the authors' own statement, makes up the bulk of Pluribus. No provider and no instance type are named, and spot prices move — this is the authors' arithmetic, not an invoice.

Basis: the match hardware alone
No figure

Nobody published what the playing machine cost. The configuration is known — two Xeon E5-2695 v3 processors and under 128 GB of memory — but not the price paid for it. By 2019 those processors were off Intel's price list: the chip was five years old, bought second-hand or already sitting in the lab.

The consumer price index measures a basket of housing, food, fuel and medical care in which computing equipment is a fraction of a per cent. The conversion above answers how much bread the machine cost, not how much cheaper computing has become — the difference is enormous and is worked through on What winning cost.

What the human still held
At the end of 2019

By this site's list, at the end of 2019 machines had not yet beaten the best people at 1 game. The year each of them finally fell is in brackets: Gran Turismo (2022).

And in this year the human did not only hold but won: “Debate: the human still wins” — the card above.

The list holds only the games this site has a date for, and it will never be complete. Nor is the board the whole line: the abilities the site measures with its own tests — reaction, working memory, mental arithmetic and 7 more — have no crossing year at all, so they cannot be laid out by year and are not laid out here. They are gathered on The limits of a human.

What stood on the desk
The processors of 2019 from the catalogue

Three axes on which the chips of 2019 can be compared, and who is at the top of each.

AxisChipAs the catalogue has itCompared
Most transistorsAMD EPYC 774240B2
Finest processAMD Ryzen 5 3600, AMD EPYC 77427 nm3
Highest clockAMD Ryzen 5 36003.6–4.2 GHz3

There is no “best” row here. The catalogue holds no comparable measurement of performance: what its chart is drawn from are approximate ratings — reconstructed rather than measured for the older parts, spread over four different scales — and some chips in every year carry none at all. Ranking on them would display a precision the data does not have, and calling the chip with the most transistors “best” would dress a value judgement as a measurement. The three axes above are quantities with units, and their leaders disagree more often than they agree. The catalogue keeps clock speeds as a range covering a family's whole life, and the comparison above takes the top of it — a top that may belong to a later year than this page.

ProcessorVendorProcessTransistorsClock
AMD Ryzen 5 3600AMD7 nm3.8B3.6–4.2 GHz
AMD EPYC 7742AMD7 nm40B2.25–3.4 GHz
Baikal-MBaikal Electronics28 nm—1.5 GHz

Figures from this site's processor catalogue. A dash means the catalogue does not carry the value, not that it is zero.

Neighbouring years