← All matches

Libratus versus four professionals

poker · 2017 · the machine won the match

Who played whom

The person: Jason Les, Dong Kim, Daniel McAulay, Jimmy Chou
The machine: Libratus
Behind the machine: Carnegie Mellon University; computing at the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center
Where: Pittsburgh, Rivers Casino — though the thinking happened half an hour away, on the Bridges supercomputer
Game: poker, 2017
Result: the machine won the match

Twenty days, 11–30 January 2017, and 120,000 hands of heads-up no-limit hold'em. The machine finished 147 milli-big-blinds per hand ahead at 99.98% statistical significance, and beat each of the four men separately as well.

What is proved and what is not

These two lists are the reason the page exists. A match is a result about a particular series of games under particular conditions, and almost everything usually drawn from one does not follow from it.

Proved

  • Hidden information stopped being a refuge. For the first time a machine beat top heads-up no-limit specialists — 147 milli-big-blinds per hand at 99.98% significance.
  • The distance was real. 120,000 hands over 20 days is not six games: at that length luck subtracts out, and the machine beat each of the four men individually as well.
  • Nobody programmed the strategy in. It was produced algorithmically, from self-play, and the algorithms are not specific to poker.

NOT proved

  • That poker is solved. Heads-up no-limit hold'em has on the order of 10^161 decision points; Libratus played an abstraction of 10^12 and refined it with subgames as play went along. No equilibrium of the real game was computed, then or since.
  • That the method carries to a table with more players. The guarantee that an equilibrium strategy cannot be beaten holds only in two-player zero-sum games and vanishes at three or more — a point Brown and Sandholm make themselves two years later, introducing Pluribus.
  • That the machine read the men. Libratus built no model of its opponents: it played toward equilibrium, and the nightly self-improvement module studied not the humans but the holes in its own abstraction that the humans kept finding.
  • That the two sides worked under comparable conditions. The machine had 196 nodes for its blueprint, some 600 nodes on playing days, and a supercomputer every night. The men had the night, and each other to talk to.
  • That comparing the sides by energy shows anything. Almost none of the electricity was spent at the table: 6 million core hours on the blueprint and another 13 million on exploratory work, against an unknown share of the 3 million that went on the hands themselves. Training and play are different quantities and cannot be added.
Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Byron Spice, Garrett Allen, 2017

The hardware

Computing units
600 nodesR · reconstructed

Regular-memory nodes of the Bridges supercomputer: two fourteen-core Intel Xeon E5-2695 v3 processors at 2.3 GHz and 128 GB of RAM apiece, so 28 cores to a node. How many nodes depends on which part of the system is meant, and the sources differ because they describe different things. Brown and Sandholm (IJCAI-18): equilibrium finding and the self-improvement module ran on 196 nodes, with the agent using only 14 of each node's 28 cores; the subgame solver took 50 nodes per game in progress. Carnegie Mellon's press release of 31 January 2017 says roughly 600 of Bridges' 846 nodes were in use during the competition. These do not contradict each other: 600 is the whole occupied machine across a playing day, parallel tables and the overnight recomputation included, while 50 and 196 are single modules. The record carries 600 — that is what was running while the men sat at the table.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Byron Spice, Garrett Allen, 2017; Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center, 2015

Energy

Every line here states the boundary it was measured inside, and the boundary is printed above the number rather than under it: eight hundred watts of silicon and eight hundred watts at the wall are not one figure at two precisions, they are two different figures. Training and playing are kept apart for the same reason and are never added: one was spent once, before the match; the other over the hours people sat at the table.

Boundary: playing the games
12,000–144,000 WR · reconstructed
where this number comes from

Reconstructed from the configuration; nobody put a meter on the wall. The Xeon E5-2695 v3 carries a 120 W nameplate TDP (Intel specification) and a Bridges node holds two of them, so 240 W of silicon per node. The low end of the range is the 50 nodes per game in progress given by Brown and Sandholm: 50 × 240 = 12 kW. The high end is the roughly 600 occupied nodes in Carnegie Mellon's press release: 600 × 240 = 144 kW. Processors only — memory, disks, the Omni-Path fabric, power-supply losses and room cooling are all outside the number, so the draw at the wall was appreciably larger. Total match energy converts badly from core hours: Brown and Sandholm allot about 3 million core hours to the subgame solver and the same again to self-improvement, but never say what share of those hours belonged to the 120,000 hands rather than to debugging. Read the core hour two ways — 14 used cores per node, or all 28 — and 3 million core hours come to between 26 and 51 MWh, which is 0.8 to 1.5 MJ per hand. That is one and a half orders of magnitude away from Pluribus's 4.8 kJ per hand, and it is why these two records belong side by side.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Byron Spice, Garrett Allen, 2017; Intel, 2014
Boundary: training the model
47,040 WR · reconstructed
where this number comes from

Reconstructed from the configuration. 196 Bridges nodes × 240 W of silicon = 47.04 kW is what the processors pulled while the strategy's blueprint was being computed. Brown and Sandholm allot about 6 million core hours to abstraction and equilibrium finding. Counting a core hour against the 14 cores the agent actually occupied, that is 429,000 node-hours — some 91 days of all 196 nodes running flat out, and roughly 103 MWh. Counting against all 28 cores of a node halves it to about 51 MWh. The paper does not say how the core hours were tallied, so the honest span is 51–103 MWh, silicon only. For scale: the whole Libratus effort came to about 25 million core hours by the same paper's reckoning, 13 million of which went on exploratory experiments and evaluation — 214–429 MWh by the same method.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center, 2015; Intel, 2014
Boundary: the whole installation at the wall
no figure was published

Not published.

where this number comes from

Neither the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center nor the Libratus authors published what the occupied share of Bridges drew at the wall, either per playing day or across the match. All that exists is a reconstruction from the processors' nameplate TDP, and that sets a floor, not a ceiling.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018

What it cost

Prices are held in the money of their own year and inside a stated boundary: the match hardware, the whole project and rented computation are three different sums, and which one is on offer is written above each.

What is counted: no boundary established
no figure was published

There is no invoice, and that is the point. Bridges was built with United States National Science Foundation money; time on it is allocated by XSEDE grants rather than sold. Neither the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center nor the authors published an internal rate per machine hour, nor an estimate of what 25 million core hours would have cost in a commercial cloud. The only firm money around the match is the purse: $200,000 split among the four professionals. The machine finished $1,766,250 up in chips, but that is a scoreline, not money — nobody was playing his own.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Byron Spice, Garrett Allen, 2017

Time

Time control

there was no clock on a decision: 120,000 hands over 20 days, about 1,500 hands a day for each of the four players

The person, per move
no figure was published
The machine, per move
no figure was published
Positions per second
no figure was published

Neither an average machine decision time nor a human one appears in the sources checked here, so both lines stay empty. What is firm: the match ran 20 days and held 120,000 hands, which is roughly 1,500 hands a day for each of the four men playing. That is arithmetic on published figures, not a measurement of tempo. One feature of the format has no equivalent in chess: every night after play the self-improvement module took over the supercomputer and patched the holes in its own abstraction that the humans had found during the day. Overnight, the human side could only talk to each other.

Sources: N. Brown, T. Sandholm, 2018; Byron Spice, Garrett Allen, 2017

The human side

On any chart the human side needs at least two lines: the brain (20 W) and the person at the board (105–126 W). A single line against the machine's watts is not a comparison, it is a choice of answer. And neither line is truly commensurable with the machine's: the machine's number excludes its training, and the human's excludes the twenty years it took to learn the game.

the brain at rest · one organ
20 WR · reconstructed

The adult brain at rest. A physiological floor, not the price of a single move.

where this number comes from

The twenty watts is a conversion, not a meter reading, and two independent routes arrive at it. One: Raichle and Gusnard (PNAS, 2002) give the brain as roughly 2% of body weight and roughly 20% of the body's oxygen and calorie consumption; 20% of an adult's basal rate (see body_resting, 60–90 W) is 12–18 W, and 20% of a seated person's rate (100–125 W) is 20–25 W. The other route is more direct: the classic Kety–Schmidt measurements put the brain's oxygen consumption at 3.3–4.0 ml per 100 g per minute (Sokoloff et al., 1955). For a 1,400 g brain that is 46–56 ml of oxygen a minute, and at an energy equivalent of about 20.9 J per ml it comes to 16–20 W. Both routes land on 16–21 W, and 20 is the rounding up. This does not earn an M: oxygen was measured, watts were not.

Sources: M. E. Raichle, D. A. Gusnard, 2002; L. Sokoloff et al., 1955
basal metabolism · the whole body at rest
60–90 WR · reconstructed

The whole body at rest — basal metabolic rate. An adult lying down, fasted, thermally comfortable.

where this number comes from

Converted from kilocalories per day. One kcal/day = 4,184 J / 86,400 s = 0.04843 W. The Mifflin–St Jeor equation (1990), now the working standard in place of Harris–Benedict: a man of 70 kg, 175 cm, 40 years gives 1,599 kcal/day, which is 77 W; a man of 80 kg, 180 cm, 30 years gives 1,780 kcal/day, 86 W; a woman of 60 kg, 162 cm, 40 years gives 1,252 kcal/day, 61 W. Hence 60–90 W, covering ordinary adults of either sex. This is lying down and fasted; a person sitting at a board spends more — see the next row.

Sources: M. D. Mifflin et al., 1990
a person at the board · the whole body, seated
105–126 WR · reconstructed

A person sitting at a board. If watts are going to be set against watts, this is the honest figure to use.

where this number comes from

From the metabolic heat production tables underlying the thermal comfort standards ISO 8996 and ASHRAE 55. The 'met' is defined as 58.2 W per square metre of body surface and describes a person seated at rest in thermal neutrality. The standard adult is 70 kg, 175 cm, with a DuBois surface area of 1.8 m². That gives: seated quiet, 1.0 met — 105 W; seated at office work, 1.2 met — 126 W. This is the body's total heat output, not the brain's share. A caveat: the ISO and ASHRAE tables descend from Passmore and Durnin's 1967 review and have not been revisited since. The spread among advisers — '70–100' against '100–120' — is not a disagreement but two different definitions: basal rate in the first case, a seated person in the second. '150–300 W' for someone sitting is simply wrong: on the same tables 150–210 W is standing and light physical work, and 300 W is walking.

Sources: International Organization for Standardization, 2021; ASHRAE, 2023
what thinking adds · the whole brain, task-evoked
no figure was published

The increment from hard mental work. There is no reliable figure, and that is itself the finding: the increment is small enough to be hard to measure at all.

where this number comes from

The most direct test was done seventy years ago and has not been overturned. Sokoloff, Mangold, Wechsler, Kennedy and Kety (Journal of Clinical Investigation, 1955) measured cerebral blood flow and oxygen consumption in 13 people at rest and while doing mental arithmetic. The EEG changed unmistakably during the arithmetic — a shift to low-voltage, high-frequency activity — and pulse and blood pressure rose, while the brain's oxygen consumption did not move: in their words, the control and arithmetic values were identical. The authors state the conclusion worth remembering the paper for: neither the degree of mental activity nor the EEG pattern correlates with total cerebral oxygen consumption. Modern imaging did not overturn this so much as sharpen it. Locally, blood flow in a working region rises a great deal; across the whole brain, the task-evoked increase is usually under 5% of the ongoing baseline (Raichle and Mintun, Annual Review of Neuroscience, 2006). Five per cent of 20 W is under a watt, and that is a ceiling rather than a reading. What is not here and will not be: the claim that a grandmaster burns 6,000 kilocalories a day. It comes from an ESPN piece of 2019 quoting Robert Sapolsky, and traces back to a tripled breathing rate multiplied by 2,000 kcal. No calorimeter appears anywhere in that chain. What does rise during a hard game is sympathetic arousal — heart rate, blood pressure, breathing, muscle tone. That raises the whole body's expenditure, not the brain's, and how much it raises it over a chess match has never been published.

Sources: L. Sokoloff et al., 1955; M. E. Raichle, M. A. Mintun, 2006; Aishwarya Kumar, 2019; Andrew Gelman, 2025

These four lines are the same on all nine pages, because the human side of the table was the same in all nine matches. Twenty watts is the brain and not the person: what sat at the board was a whole body, and setting an organ against a machine's wall socket is a way of choosing the answer in advance.

Sources

ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55: Thermal Environmental Conditions for Human Occupancy (the table of metabolic rates: seated quiet 1.0 met, seated office work 1.2 met; the standard adult's DuBois surface area 1.8 m²)
ASHRAE · ANSI/ASHRAE 55-2023 · 2023 · book · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Price Index for Private Fixed Investment: Information Processing Equipment: Computers and Peripheral Equipment (series B935RG3A086NBEA; the fall stops around 2011 and the index rises from 2020)
U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis · FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · 2026 · web page · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Producer Price Index by Industry: Electronic Computer Manufacturing (series PCU334111334111; the same shape: a plateau from the early 2010s, rising from 2020)
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics · FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · 2026 · web page · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Libratus: The Superhuman AI for No-Limit Poker (Demonstration) (the “Agent Construction” section: about 25 million core-hours in all, of which some 13 million went on search experiments, 6 million on abstraction and equilibrium finding, 3 million on subgame solving and 3 million on self-improvement; 196 Bridges nodes of 28 cores and 128 GB, the agent itself holding 14 cores; the subgame solver ran on 50 nodes per game)
N. Brown, T. Sandholm · Proceedings of the Twenty-Seventh International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence (IJCAI-18), pp. 5226–5228 · 2018 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Carnegie Mellon Artificial Intelligence Beats Top Poker Pros (120,000 hands, a margin of $1,766,250 in chips, a $200,000 prize pool, “approximately 600 of Bridges' 846 compute nodes”, the strategy recomputed overnight)
Byron Spice, Garrett Allen · Carnegie Mellon University News, 31 January 2017 · 2017 · press · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
The grandmaster diet: How to lose weight while barely moving (where the “6,000 calories a day” figure comes from, credited to Robert Sapolsky; no calorimetry underneath it)
Aishwarya Kumar · ESPN, 13 September 2019 · 2019 · press · secondary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers: All Items in U.S. City Average, annual, not seasonally adjusted (series CPIAUCNS; a snapshot of the annual averages, 1913–2025)
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics · FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis · 2026 · web page · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
About that bogus claim that “chess grandmasters” burn 6000 calories per day (where the number came from: respiration measured on 11 ordinary players, the highest reading passed off as the average, multiplied against 2,000 kcal)
Andrew Gelman · Statistical Modeling, Causal Inference, and Social Science, 30 June 2025 · 2025 · web page · secondary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Intel Xeon Processor E5-2695 v3 (35M Cache, 2.30 GHz) — Product Specifications: 14 cores, 28 threads, 2.30 GHz base, 3.30 GHz turbo, 22 nm, 120 W TDP, launched Q3 2014
Intel · Intel Product Specifications (ARK), SKU 81057 · 2014 · vendor document · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
ISO 8996: Ergonomics of the thermal environment — Determination of metabolic rate (tables of metabolic heat production by activity; 1 met = 58.2 W/m²)
International Organization for Standardization · ISO 8996:2021 · 2021 · book · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
A new predictive equation for resting energy expenditure in healthy individuals (the Mifflin–St Jeor equation)
M. D. Mifflin, S. T. St Jeor, L. A. Hill, B. J. Scott, S. A. Daugherty, Y. O. Koh · American Journal of Clinical Nutrition 51(2), pp. 241–247 · 1990 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Two Centuries of Productivity Growth in Computing (table 10: the official BEA hedonic index — the real price of computing falling 18.7% a year over 1969–2004; the performance-based measure — 50.7% a year over 1969–2005)
W. D. Nordhaus · The Journal of Economic History 67(1), pp. 128–159 · 2007 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Bridges RSM (Regular Shared Memory) nodes: two 14-core Intel Xeon E5-2695 v3 at 2.3 GHz and 128 GB of memory per node
Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center · psc.edu, the page describing the Bridges configuration (it has since moved; the configuration is corroborated by Brown and Sandholm — 28 cores and 128 GB per node — and by the Pluribus paper, which names the same processor model outright) · 2015 · vendor document · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Appraising the brain's energy budget (the brain is about 2% of body mass and takes about 20% of the oxygen and the calories the body uses; the rate is remarkably constant across widely varying mental and motor activity)
M. E. Raichle, D. A. Gusnard · Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 99(16), pp. 10237–10239 · 2002 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
Brain Work and Brain Imaging (the increase in the brain's energy use that a task brings about is small next to the baseline — usually under 5%)
M. E. Raichle, M. A. Mintun · Annual Review of Neuroscience 29, pp. 449–476 · 2006 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12
The Effect of Mental Arithmetic on Cerebral Circulation and Metabolism (13 subjects; doing arithmetic in the head shifts the EEG and raises pulse and blood pressure, while cerebral blood flow and the brain's oxygen consumption do not move; control CMRO₂ 3.3–4.0 ml O₂ per 100 g per minute)
L. Sokoloff, R. Mangold, R. L. Wechsler, C. Kennedy, S. S. Kety · Journal of Clinical Investigation 34(7), pp. 1101–1108 · 1955 · paper · primary
original · archived copy · checked 2026-08-12